If you had asked me to choose between an electric and a gas lawnmower a few years back, I would have said the gas mower. The electric lawn mowers are now comparable to their big brother, the gas model due to technological advances in battery and motor technology.

What will it matter which mower you choose? At the end of the day, it’s all about which mower can get the job done the way you need it to. There are many options. It will come down to which mower best suits your needs. There are many options available, but not all of them will be right for you. So, let’s take a closer look at the considerations you should make.

Which Mower Should You Choose? (The Short Answer)

Both gasoline-powered and electric lawnmowers have their strengths as well as weaknesses.  Each mower type has a limit on the size of the lawn they can cut without interruption. This should be your primary consideration. Next, you’ll want to take a look at your own abilities. A heavy, gas-powered mower requires a lot of physical energy. An electric model might be more suitable for you. Don’t buy a mower that is too large. In some cases, an electric mower may be more efficient than a gas model.

Power SourcePro’s
Gas-poweredThere is a lot of power
Long run time
Durable
Larger models
Electric – BatteryNo need for gas
Low maintenance
Lightweight
Simple to use
Electric – CordedLow maintenance
Endless run time
Lightweight
Simple to use

Gas Lawn Mowers – The pros and cons

Gas-powered lawn mowers have won the battle of electric vs gas mowers. Most homeowners prefer gas-powered mowers. Because they are what most homeowners know and have used before, this is a good reason. Let’s take a closer look at why gas-powered lawn mowers are a popular choice.

There is a lot of power

The size of the engine is what determines how powerful a gas lawnmower. A larger engine will give you more power. This is a simple option and allows you to easily purchase a gas-powered lawnmower that is suitable for your yard.

When comparing gas or electric lawn mowers, it’s easy to see that a middle-of-the-road gas-powered mower has, on average, twice the power of an electric mower. A gas-powered mower is the best choice if you have a lot of fast-growing grass and hilly areas.

Long Run Time

A gas-powered lawnmower can run as long as it needs to as long you have enough gasoline. Refilling the gas tank only takes a moment, and you’ll be up and running again in no time. If you rely on batteries, then you’ll have to take a long break while they recharge.

Durability

Gas-powered lawnmowers can last for up to ten years if taken care of. They are built from sturdy metal and can withstand a few bumps, but they will keep going. As long as you stay on top of services and maintenance, there’s no reason for a gas-powered mower to stop working.

Larger Models

If cut width is an important factor and you don’t want to move up to a riding mower, then you’ll find the gas-powered model has the widest cutting deck. Finding a 21-inch deck on an electric battery isn’t difficult, but you’ll struggle with anything bigger. In comparison, it’s easy to find gas-powered models larger than 50-inches. A gas-powered mower is the best option if you have a big lawn.

Electric Lawn Mowers – The pros

The battery-powered lawnmower has emerged as the new entrant on the market. Manufacturers are looking for alternative mowing solutions to reduce carbon emissions as a result of growing environmental concerns. Electric mowers are now more appealing than ever because they can be operated without the use of a cord and have enough power to match their gas counterparts. So, let’s see how an electric/battery mower shines in the cutting department.

No Gas Required

The electric mower emits zero emissions, which is the first benefit. This alone is enough to convince some people that electric mowing is the best option. Additionally, storing gas isn’t always possible for some, so batteries are a perfect solution. Finally, it’s unlikely you’ll ever run out of electricity, so you can always keep your mower charged. It’s definitely more convenient than having to run to the gas station every time you run out of gas.

Low Maintenance

An electric mower is much easier to maintain than a gas-powered model. You still need to sharpen your blade and keep your mower clean, but that’s about it. Air filters, sparkplugs and fuel additives should not be a concern.

There’s really very little you need to do to keep your electric/battery mower going other than charging the batteries and sharpening the blades. If you don’t like engines, tools, or greasy hands, an electric/battery mower is the right choice.

Lightweight

One of the greatest advantages of battery mowers over gas mowers is their lighter weight. This is because they don’t have a big engine or fuel tank and are mostly made of high-strength plastics. If you want to go even lighter, then a corded electric mower could be an option for you as they don’t have the weight of a battery.

Simple to use

Their ease of use is the last thing on the list. Electric lawn mowers simply require you to pull the lever, and you’re off. There’s no special starting procedure like for gas engines or any servicing issues that can cause poor performance.

Additionally, lithium batteries are so advanced that you’ll be able to work the mower at full power through the whole charge of the battery. So, as long as you have enough charge in the battery, you won’t have any problems.

If you are using a corded mower, then you won’t even have to worry about charging; just plug it in, and you’re off.

Factors that will impact your decision

As you can see, the three types are capable of doing the job. Nevertheless, you want to make sure that you make the right choice and pick the mower that’s going to suit you and your lawn the best. So, let’s take a look at the factors that will affect your decision.

Size of Lawn

The size of your lawn is the first thing to consider. As long as there is enough gasoline, gas mowers are capable of cutting large lawns. But, a battery mower will only cut as long as it has a charge. Most manufacturers claim that their batteries can cut for up to an hour. This is for a perfect battery. As batteries get older, they hold less charge, so it’s unlikely you’ll get an hour of cutting on a single charge forever.

If you have a sizeable yard,  then a corded mower is not really a good choice since they don’t have long enough cords to reach all the areas of a large yard. Extending the cord is an option, but you’ll start to lose power with longer cables. A larger gauge cable can help to prevent power loss, but it can be expensive.

Types of Lawn

Different grass types may require different power to cut correctly. You need to ensure that the mower you choose has enough power to cut your lawn cleanly. If your lawn has a coarse grass type or pesky weeds then ensure the mower has enough power.

Reduced Time

Mowers that have less power will take longer to cut your lawn. If you have a slow lawn to mow, a lawnmower with less power will cut your lawn faster. If your lawn is easy to cut in ten to fifteen minutes, a large mower may be unnecessary.

Mower Storage

When buying a new lawn mower, it is important to consider where you will store it. For example, if you’re only able to store your mower inside your home, then a gasoline version is probably not going to be a good idea because of the gas fumes. The size of the mower that you need will depend on how much storage space you have.

Cost of purchase

If you’re looking for a new mower, cost is likely to be your top priority. While corded mowers are the most cost-effective type available, they aren’t a good choice for large lawns. So if you have a sizeable lawn, then you’re left to choose between gas and battery-powered mowers. If you are looking for equal power between a gas and battery mower, then you’ll need to look at a top-of-the-line battery-powered mower to try to match a middle-of-the-road gas model.

If cost is a concern, lithium batteries can be quite expensive if you need a lot of power and a long life span. You should expect to spend a lot for a high-end mower battery.

Mower/Engine Knowledge

Although you get more value and performance with a gas mower than a conventional one, they can be complicated and require some mechanical knowledge. So if you don’t know much about engines and don’t want to get oil under your nails, a gas-powered mower may not be a good fit for you.

My Recommendations on When to Use a Gas Mower or an Electric Mower

It can be difficult to choose between electric and gas mowers with so many great options. To help you choose the right mower for your job, I created a chart that matches different lawn types. I can guarantee that a mower that fits your yard will make a big difference.

Flat, small lawnCorded, Battery and Gas
Small, Bumpy LawnCorded, Battery and Gas
Small, Sloped LawnCorded, Battery and Gas
Medium or Flat LawnBattery and Gas
Medium, Bumpy LawnBattery and Gas
Sloped Lawn, MediumBattery and Gas
Large, Flat LawnGas
Large, Bumpy LawnGas
Large, Sloped LawnGas

Which is the best for you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.